Independent vs U-Store-It: Storage Prices Compared

7 size categories compared · Updated November 2026
✓

Independent is cheaper overall

Independent wins on price in 4 of 7 size categories.

As of November 2026, Independent operates 64 facilities while U-Store-It has 7. For medium units, Independent averages $244/month vs U-Store-It at $263/month. Independent is cheaper on average across most size brackets.

Independent
Facilities 64
States NSW, NT, QLD, SA, TAS, VIC, WA
Brackets won 4 of 7
U-Store-It
Facilities 7
States SA
Brackets won 3 of 7

Price Comparison Score

Independent: 4 wins U-Store-It: 3 wins

Price Comparison by Unit Size

Size Independent U-Store-It Cheaper
Locker (< 2 m²) $73/mo avg
44 units at 28 facilities
$64/mo avg
4 units at 4 facilities
US
12% cheaper
Small (2–5 m²) $155/mo avg
140 units at 44 facilities
$134/mo avg
20 units at 6 facilities
US
14% cheaper
Medium (5–10 m²) $244/mo avg
235 units at 52 facilities
$263/mo avg
49 units at 7 facilities
IND
7% cheaper
Large (10–20 m²) $386/mo avg
263 units at 56 facilities
$435/mo avg
25 units at 6 facilities
IND
11% cheaper
Extra Large (20–40 m²) $530/mo avg
63 units at 29 facilities
$390/mo avg
6 units at 3 facilities
US
26% cheaper
Garage+ (40+ m²) $914/mo avg
5 units at 4 facilities
$4480/mo avg
1 units at 1 facilities
IND
80% cheaper
Vehicle / Parking $238/mo avg
25 units at 13 facilities
$280/mo avg
8 units at 3 facilities
IND
15% cheaper

Other Provider Comparisons

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Independent or U-Store-It cheaper?
Based on national average prices, Independent is cheaper than U-Store-It across the majority of unit size categories. However, prices vary by location — compare prices in your specific suburb for the most accurate result.
How many locations do Independent and U-Store-It have?
Independent has 64 facilities with available pricing, while U-Store-It has 7. Facility counts reflect locations where we have current pricing data.
Which states do Independent and U-Store-It operate in?
Independent operates in NSW, NT, QLD, SA, TAS, VIC, WA. U-Store-It operates in SA.
Which is better for a medium storage unit — Independent or U-Store-It?
For medium units (5-10 m²), Independent averages $244/month and U-Store-It averages $263/month nationally. Independent is the cheaper option on average for this size.
Browse all storage → · All provider comparisons →

Compare Prices in Your Suburb

See Independent and U-Store-It prices side by side for your specific location.

Compare prices